Sign up to stay up to date on the Gardner Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
509 Peach Tree Circle 4 3.5 2,808 $535,000 $190 Unknown
805 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,234 $332,995 $269 Unknown
829 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,446 $359,995 $248 Unknown
837 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,703 $374,995 $220 Unknown
890 N Pear Street 3 2 1,328 $338,490 $254 Unknown
789 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,216 $314,991 $259 Unknown
328 N Cherry Street 3 2 1,638 $370,000 $225 Unknown
628 E Dogwood Street 3 3 1,844 $369,950 $200 Unknown
17674 Jubilee Street 4 2 1,980 $420,065 $212 Unknown
713 S Meadowbrook Street 4 2 1,576 $350,000 $222 Unknown
533 N Mulberry Street 3 2.5 1,909 $324,900 $170 Unknown
728 S Maple Street 3 2 1,595 $348,000 $218 Unknown
844 S Woodson Court 2 2.5 1,352 $215,000 $159 Unknown
333 N Cherry Street 3 2.5 1,900 $320,000 $168 Unknown
32078 W 170th Terrace 5 3 2,389 $441,900 $184 Unknown
17806 Green Road 4 3 2,190 $515,990 $235 Unknown
31749 W 168th Court 4 3 2,292 $520,000 $226 Unknown
17682 Jubilee Street 3 2 1,522 $376,595 $247 Unknown
16367 Baxter Street 4 3 2,524 $586,760 $232 Unknown
561 N Evergreen Street 4 3 2,664 $479,000 $179 Unknown
15855 Gardner West Road 3 2.5 3,328 $474,900 $142 Unknown
20280 S Gardner Road N/A N/A N/A $750,000 Unknown Unknown
16268 Baxter Street 4 3 2,873 $679,230 $236 Unknown
16264 Baxter Street 4 3 2,616 $668,890 $255 Unknown
16356 Baxter Street 4 3 2,904 $696,540 $239 Unknown
17749 Greeley Street 4 3.5 2,292 $500,000 $218 Unknown
14555 Oak Valley Drive 5 4 4,376 $1,600,000 $365 Unknown
17565 Spivey Street 4 2 1,980 $415,800 $210 Unknown
17546 Muncie Street 3 2 1,690 $399,990 $236 Unknown
17561 Spivey Street 3 2 1,522 $359,990 $236 Unknown
15060 Sycamore Street N/A N/A N/A $220,000 Unknown Unknown
31700 W 164th Court 5 4.5 3,281 $550,000 $167 Unknown
24840 W 178th Court 4 2.5 2,195 $520,000 $236 Unknown
640 Lanesfield Street 3 2 1,780 $370,000 $207 Unknown
31780 W 172nd Street 3 2 1,510 $342,500 $226 Unknown
31940 W 172nd Street 4 2 1,560 $349,900 $224 Unknown
28501 W 161st Terrace 4 3.5 2,267 $524,000 $231 Unknown
28601 W 162nd Street 4 3.5 2,782 $545,500 $196 Unknown
572 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,216 $328,990 $270 Unknown
201 N Poplar Drive 4 2.5 2,199 $385,000 $175 Unknown
17824 Green Road 5 3 2,412 $533,990 $221 Unknown
25261 W 177th Terrace 5 3.5 2,556 $473,990 $185 Unknown
32077 W 170th Terrace 4 2.5 1,973 $448,900 $227 Unknown
16439 Blair Street 3 2.5 1,851 $339,950 $183 Unknown
26732 W 191st Street N/A N/A N/A $499,000 Unknown Unknown
17536 Muncie Street 3 2 1,690 $379,990 $224 Unknown
17542 Muncie Street 3 2 1,522 $399,990 $262 Unknown
17552 Muncie Street 3 2 1,522 $369,900 $243 Unknown
25254 W 177th Terrace 4 3 2,511 $469,990 $187 Unknown
269 W Cheyenne Street 4 2.5 1,961 $360,000 $183 Unknown
Average: 3.8 2.7 2,146 $844,717 $214 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 91
Viewing 1 - 50 of 91
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
17569 Spivey Street 3 2 1,337 $343,185 $256 Unknown
524 E Hawthorn Street 3 3 1,670 $330,000 $197 Unknown
883 N Pear Street 3 2 1,234 $326,490 $264 Unknown
142 W Shawnee Street 3 1 1,040 $200,000 $192 Unknown
549 S Woodson Lane 3 2 1,574 $225,000 $142 Unknown
847 E Pinewood Street 3 1.5 1,548 $249,950 $161 Unknown
512 E Cheyenne Street 3 3 2,450 $334,900 $136 Unknown
891 N Pear Street 3 2 1,216 $319,991 $263 Unknown
882 N Pear Street 3 2 1,703 $362,990 $213 Unknown
830 N Buckeye Street 4 2 1,840 $386,995 $210 Unknown
590 S Pine Street 3 2 1,616 $360,000 $222 Unknown
800 S Woodson Court 3 2.5 1,445 $230,000 $159 Unknown
840 E Cheyenne Street 3 3.5 2,463 $392,000 $159 Unknown
740 E Valerie Lane 3 1.5 2,010 $294,900 $146 Unknown
571 S Meadowbrook Street 3 2 1,585 $379,950 $239 Unknown
16820 Scott Street 5 2.5 2,762 $504,900 $182 Unknown
858 N Pear Street 3 2 1,703 $369,540 $216 Unknown
32493 W 168th Court 4 3 2,980 $539,900 $181 Unknown
724 S Woodson Lane 2 3 2,240 $260,000 $116 Unknown
256 N ALDER Street 3 2 1,960 $320,000 $163 Unknown
734 S Cypress Street 3 2 1,510 $337,500 $223 Unknown
848 N Alder Street 5 3 2,906 $488,888 $168 Unknown
525 Parma Way 3 2.5 1,793 $350,000 $195 Unknown
31855 W 171st Street 4 2 1,560 $349,900 $224 Unknown
749 S Cypress Street 3 2 1,510 $337,500 $223 Unknown
29313 W 152nd Street 3 3 1,636 $495,000 $302 Unknown
16328 Baxter Street 4 3 2,904 $698,050 $240 Unknown
32750 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,980 $399,990 $202 Unknown
32742 W 175th Terrace 3 2 1,690 $369,990 $218 Unknown
31757 W 168th Court 4 2.5 2,358 $525,000 $222 Unknown
620 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,216 $315,000 $259 Unknown
725 N Alder Street 4 3.5 2,264 $377,500 $166 Unknown
14850 Oak Valley Drive 3 2.5 3,540 $795,000 $224 Unknown
215 N Maple Street 3 2 2,087 $319,000 $152 Unknown
920 PUMPKIN RIDGE Street 4 2 1,738 $323,950 $186 Unknown
393 W ACORN Street 3 2.5 1,622 $282,000 $173 Unknown
840 S Woodson Court 3 3 1,445 $210,000 $145 Unknown
17686 Jubilee Street 4 2 1,781 $377,500 $211 Unknown
629 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,703 $380,160 $223 Unknown
17694 Jubilee Street 3 2 1,337 $338,500 $253 Unknown
32094 W 170th Terrace 4 3 2,501 $454,900 $181 Unknown
17520 New Trails Parkway N/A N/A N/A $5,400,000 Unknown Unknown
32751 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,980 $399,990 $202 Unknown
32759 W 176th Terrace 3 2 1,522 $373,301 $245 Unknown
17621 Spivey Street 3 2 1,690 $400,134 $236 Unknown
25236 W 177th Terrace 3 2 1,659 $419,990 $253 Unknown
17558 Muncie Street 3 2 1,690 $422,400 $249 Unknown
527 S Poplar Street 4 2.5 1,938 $360,000 $185 Unknown
25285 W 177th Terrace 5 3 2,412 $446,990 $185 Unknown
31933 W 170th Terrace 4 3 2,575 $444,900 $172 Unknown
Average: 3.6 2.5 2,055 $558,004 $203 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 68
Viewing 1 - 50 of 68
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
961 Oak Crest Drive 3 2.5 1,621 $330,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/9/26
835 N Pear Street 4 2 1,735 $368,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/4/26
834 N Pear Street 3 2 1,234 $314,156 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/4/26
26870 W 199th Street N/A N/A N/A $205,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/4/26
597 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,216 $329,865 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/4/26
29509 W 196th Street 4 3.5 2,200 $489,950 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/4/26
880 N Alder Street 3 3 2,144 $379,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/3/26
32643 W 172nd Street 4 2.5 1,395 $310,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/3/26
17839 Houston Street 4 3.5 2,447 $505,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/3/26
31815 W 171st Street 3 2 1,561 $332,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/1/26
604 S Hickory Street 3 1 1,008 $260,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/1/26
17736 Greeley Street 5 4.5 3,396 $535,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/1/26
32247 W 165 Street 4 3 2,800 $590,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/1/26
17149 Jessica Street 3 2 1,417 $305,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/31/26
17168 S Pratt Street 3 2 1,510 $337,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/31/26
613 W Bluebird Street 4 2 1,496 $349,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/31/26
621 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,328 $328,941 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/31/26
826 N Pear Street 3 2 1,703 $372,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
15285 Edgerton Road 4 2.5 1,904 $487,750 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
636 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,355 $349,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
28902 W 150th Street 5 5.5 4,428 $1,175,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
230 W Skylark Street 3 3 2,374 $375,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
628 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,770 $371,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
25224 W 177th Terrace 4 2.5 2,356 $444,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
25260 W 177th Terrace 4 3 2,190 $429,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/28/26
25249 W 177th Terrace 3 2 1,498 $402,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/27/26
32719 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,980 $389,885 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/27/26
16441 Ingalls Street 4 3.5 2,505 $611,870 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/27/26
371 N Birch Street 3 2 1,170 $280,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/26/26
21455 S Moonlight Road 3 2 1,196 $350,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/26/26
25231 W 177th Terrace 4 2 1,771 $429,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/26/26
32726 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,980 $392,435 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/25/26
31715 W 164th Terrace 4 3.5 2,341 $540,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/24/26
25218 W 177th Terrace 3 2 1,498 $386,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/24/26
25011 178th Terrace 4 3 2,511 $479,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/21/26
741 Pinewood Street 4 2 1,808 $290,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/20/26
800 S Meadowbrook Street 4 3 2,223 $390,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/20/26
433 W Bluebird Street 3 2.5 1,987 $375,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/19/26
31101 W 170th Street 4 3 2,136 $400,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/19/26
29900 W 184th Street 4 3.5 2,687 $415,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/19/26
32734 W 176th Terrace 3 2 1,522 $366,645 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/19/26
16701 Scott Street 4 4 2,859 $514,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/19/26
17350 S Agnes Street 3 2 1,313 $344,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/18/26
596 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,234 $328,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/17/26
35352 W 146th Street 3 2 2,528 $675,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/14/26
537 E Cheyenne Street 4 2 2,050 $334,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/14/26
530 S Maple Street 4 3 2,843 $400,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/14/26
744 W Shawnee Court 3 3.5 1,925 $285,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/13/26
16331 Baxter Street 5 4.5 3,279 $700,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/13/26
126 N Pecan Street 4 3 2,466 $395,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/13/26
Average: 3.5 2.5 1,956 $425,253 $0 $0 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 284
Viewing 1 - 50 of 284

The data relating to real estate displayed on this website comes in part from the Heartland Multiple Listing Service database compilation. The properties displayed on this website may not be all of the properties in the Heartland MLS database compilation, or all of the properties listed with other brokers participating in the Heartland MLS IDX program. Detailed information about the properties displayed on this website includes the name of the listing company.

The information displayed on this page is confidential, proprietary, and copyrighted information of Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. (“Heartland MLS”). Copyright 2026, Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Heartland MLS and the company represented by this website do not make any warranty or representation concerning the timeliness or accuracy of the information displayed herein. In consideration for the receipt of the information on this page, the recipient agrees to use the information solely for the private noncommercial purpose of identifying a property in which the recipient has a good faith interest in acquiring. Data last updated . Terms of Use