Sign up to stay up to date on the Gardner Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
123 E Madison Street 2 1 955 $249,000 $260 Unknown
530 W Washington Street 4 3 2,013 $400,000 $198 Unknown
416 N Hickory Street 3 2.5 1,926 $337,000 $174 Unknown
601 N Winwood Street 3 2 1,524 $325,000 $213 Unknown
29645 W 196th Street 3 2 1,547 $524,950 $339 Unknown
29637 W 196th Street 4 3 2,172 $524,950 $241 Unknown
600 S Maple Street 3 2 1,296 $337,500 $260 Unknown
749 N Buckeye Street 4 2 1,735 $366,990 $211 Unknown
766 N Buckeye Street 4 2 1,496 $349,490 $233 Unknown
774 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,328 $341,590 $257 Unknown
813 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,703 $362,290 $212 Unknown
372 W Madison Street 4 3.5 2,967 $410,000 $138 Unknown
31863 W 172nd Street 3 2 1,531 $347,500 $226 Unknown
17176 S Kill Creek Road 3 2 1,561 $337,500 $216 Unknown
116 S Oak Street 3 1.5 1,430 $225,000 $157 Unknown
28696 W 161st Street 4 3.5 2,340 $519,900 $222 Unknown
32157 W 170th Terrace 4 2.5 2,062 $458,900 $222 Unknown
17698 Jubilee Street 4 2 1,781 $402,280 $225 Unknown
17690 Jubilee Street 3 2 1,690 $369,990 $218 Unknown
17678 Jubilee Street 4 2.5 2,466 $449,990 $182 Unknown
30750 W 143rd Street 3 2 1,922 $690,000 $359 Unknown
14340 S Gardner Road 4 5.5 5,180 $1,400,000 $270 Unknown
541 E Mockingbird Street 4 2.5 2,500 $435,000 $174 Unknown
757 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,355 $346,995 $256 Unknown
853 E 167th Court 2 2.5 1,256 $235,000 $187 Unknown
945 E Cottage Creek Drive 4 2.5 1,725 $372,500 $215 Unknown
223 W Colleen Court 4 2.5 2,311 $379,950 $164 Unknown
18390 Butternut Street 3 2.5 2,325 $410,000 $176 Unknown
28414 W 162nd Street 5 4 2,604 $530,000 $203 Unknown
781 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,446 $348,845 $241 Unknown
31904 W 175th Street N/A N/A N/A $600,000 Unknown Unknown
31687 W 172nd Street 3 2 1,510 $319,900 $211 Unknown
765 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,770 $359,990 $203 Unknown
738 S Cypress Street 3 2 1,510 $339,900 $225 Unknown
561 N Evergreen Street 4 3 2,664 $467,000 $175 Unknown
17557 Spivey Street 4 2 1,980 $399,990 $202 Unknown
312 Ghost Creek Lane 4 2.5 1,876 $342,500 $182 Unknown
644 N Pear Street 3 2 1,245 $335,000 $269 Unknown
17674 Jubilee Street 4 2 1,980 $388,990 $196 Unknown
713 S Meadowbrook Street 4 2 1,576 $345,000 $218 Unknown
32078 W 170th Terrace 5 3 2,389 $441,900 $184 Unknown
17806 Green Road 4 3 2,190 $499,990 $228 Unknown
17682 Jubilee Street 3 2 1,522 $339,990 $223 Unknown
16367 Baxter Street 4 3 2,524 $586,760 $232 Unknown
15855 Gardner West Road 3 2.5 3,328 $449,999 $135 Unknown
20280 S Gardner Road N/A N/A N/A $750,000 Unknown Unknown
16268 Baxter Street 4 3 2,873 $679,230 $236 Unknown
16264 Baxter Street 4 3 2,616 $668,890 $255 Unknown
17749 Greeley Street 4 3.5 2,292 $490,000 $213 Unknown
14555 Oak Valley Drive 5 4 4,376 $1,500,000 $342 Unknown
Average: 3.7 2.6 2,094 $725,708 $216 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 93
Viewing 1 - 50 of 93
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
361 W Westhoff Place 4 2.5 2,964 $360,000 $121 Unknown
31213 W 172nd Terrace 3 2 1,412 $305,000 $216 Unknown
792 S Poplar Street 2 2 1,321 $289,950 $219 Unknown
16749 Ingalls Street 3 2.5 1,772 $355,000 $200 Unknown
758 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,216 $304,491 $250 Unknown
526 N Pear Street 3 2 1,414 $335,000 $236 Unknown
459 N Cherry Street 3 2.5 1,910 $350,000 $183 Unknown
626 S Walnut Street 4 2.5 1,518 $365,000 $240 Unknown
537 S Woodson Lane 3 2 1,341 $225,000 $167 Unknown
17671 Jubilee Street 3 2 1,337 $325,000 $243 Unknown
17585 Spivey Street 3 2 1,337 $352,928 $263 Unknown
18404 Ash Street 3 2 1,626 $375,000 $230 Unknown
724 Valerie Lane 3 1.5 1,376 $305,000 $221 Unknown
17707 Jubilee Street 4 2.5 2,695 $482,615 $179 Unknown
866 N Maple Street 4 3.5 2,681 $405,000 $151 Unknown
29201 W 183rd Terrace 3 2.5 1,772 $370,000 $208 Unknown
17188 Jennifer Street 3 2.5 1,120 $300,000 $267 Unknown
709 S Oak Street 3 1.5 1,444 $299,950 $207 Unknown
17710 Jubilee Street 4 2 1,980 $409,005 $206 Unknown
17633 Spivey Street 3 2 1,690 $393,520 $232 Unknown
17581 Spivey Street 4 2 1,980 $400,815 $202 Unknown
509 Peach Tree Circle 4 3.5 2,808 $519,000 $184 Unknown
805 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,234 $319,895 $259 Unknown
829 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,446 $351,545 $243 Unknown
837 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,703 $357,395 $209 Unknown
789 N Buckeye Street 3 2 1,216 $308,341 $253 Unknown
17569 Spivey Street 3 2 1,337 $343,185 $256 Unknown
333 N Cherry Street 3 2.5 1,900 $299,950 $157 Unknown
31749 W 168th Court 4 3 2,292 $515,000 $224 Unknown
16356 Baxter Street 4 3 2,904 $696,540 $239 Unknown
891 N Pear Street 3 2 1,216 $324,950 $267 Unknown
830 N Buckeye Street 4 2 1,840 $386,995 $210 Unknown
590 S Pine Street 3 2 1,616 $360,000 $222 Unknown
17546 Muncie Street 3 2 1,690 $379,990 $224 Unknown
16820 Scott Street 5 2.5 2,762 $504,900 $182 Unknown
32493 W 168th Court 4 3 2,980 $539,900 $181 Unknown
31700 W 164th Court 5 4.5 3,281 $550,000 $167 Unknown
31940 W 172nd Street 4 2 1,560 $339,900 $217 Unknown
724 S Woodson Lane 2 3 2,240 $260,000 $116 Unknown
572 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,216 $318,990 $262 Unknown
25261 W 177th Terrace 5 3.5 2,556 $439,990 $172 Unknown
16328 Baxter Street 4 3 2,904 $698,050 $240 Unknown
17536 Muncie Street 3 2 1,690 $349,990 $207 Unknown
17552 Muncie Street 3 2 1,522 $349,990 $229 Unknown
32750 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,980 $399,990 $202 Unknown
32742 W 175th Terrace 3 2 1,690 $369,990 $218 Unknown
14850 Oak Valley Drive 3 2.5 3,540 $705,000 $199 Unknown
432 E Pawnee Lane 3 2.5 1,854 $344,900 $186 Unknown
32758 W 175th Terrace 4 2.5 2,466 $429,990 $174 Unknown
840 S Woodson Court 3 3 1,445 $210,000 $145 Unknown
Average: 3.5 2.5 1,956 $516,096 $209 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 65
Viewing 1 - 50 of 65
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
32448 W 168th Court 5 2.5 2,763 $498,800 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/22/26
405 Birch Street 4 2 1,957 $349,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/21/26
17558 Muncie Street 3 2 1,690 $422,400 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/20/26
350 N Locust Street 3 2 1,498 $355,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/16/26
883 N Pear Street 3 2 1,234 $326,490 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/15/26
16438 AGNES Street 5 4.5 3,764 $500,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/15/26
512 E Cheyenne Street 3 3 2,450 $334,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/14/26
430 and 432 Shawnee Street N/A N/A N/A $225,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/13/26
31780 W 172nd Street 3 2 1,510 $342,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/13/26
844 S Woodson Court 2 2.5 1,352 $215,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/9/26
269 W Cheyenne Street 4 2.5 1,961 $360,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/9/26
32735 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,781 $359,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/8/26
740 E Valerie Lane 3 1.5 2,010 $294,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/6/26
18320 S Center Street N/A N/A N/A $2,800,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/6/26
628 E Dogwood Street 3 3 1,844 $359,950 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/5/26
840 E Cheyenne Street 3 3.5 2,463 $386,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/5/26
524 E Hawthorn Street 3 3 1,670 $330,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/2/26
25236 W 177th Terrace 3 2 1,659 $419,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/2/26
25285 W 177th Terrace 5 3 2,412 $446,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/2/26
549 S Woodson Lane 3 2 1,574 $225,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/1/26
848 N Alder Street 5 3 2,906 $488,888 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/1/26
525 Parma Way 3 2.5 1,793 $350,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/1/26
17827 Houston Street 4 3.5 2,452 $525,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/1/26
734 S Cypress Street 3 2 1,510 $337,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/30/26
32751 W 175th Terrace 4 2 1,980 $399,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/30/26
32158 W 170th Terrace 4 2.5 2,059 $463,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/30/26
890 N Pear Street 3 2 1,328 $338,490 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/29/26
858 N Pear Street 3 2 1,703 $369,540 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/29/26
629 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,703 $380,160 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/29/26
882 N Pear Street 3 2 1,703 $362,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/24/26
571 S Meadowbrook Street 3 2 1,585 $379,950 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/24/26
32759 W 176th Terrace 3 2 1,522 $373,301 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/23/26
32125 W 170th Terrace 5 3 2,302 $438,800 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/23/26
31757 W 168th Court 4 2.5 2,358 $525,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/22/26
31732 W 164th Terrace 3 2 1,685 $538,370 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/22/26
847 E Pinewood Street 3 1.5 1,548 $249,950 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/18/26
215 N Maple Street 3 2 2,087 $319,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/18/26
920 PUMPKIN RIDGE Street 4 2 1,738 $323,950 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/18/26
17851 Green Road 4 3.5 2,452 $469,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/18/26
31933 W 170th Terrace 4 3 2,575 $444,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/17/26
16253 Baxter Street 7 5 3,888 $797,050 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/17/26
31855 W 171st Street 4 2 1,560 $349,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
749 S Cypress Street 3 2 1,510 $337,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
29313 W 152nd Street 3 3 1,636 $495,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
620 W Bluebird Street 3 2 1,216 $315,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
25279 W 177th Terr Street 4 3 2,511 $439,990 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/14/26
256 N ALDER Street 3 2 1,960 $320,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/11/26
725 N Alder Street 4 3.5 2,264 $377,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/11/26
142 W Shawnee Street 3 1 1,040 $200,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/10/26
393 W ACORN Street 3 2.5 1,622 $282,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/10/26
Average: 3.6 2.5 1,988 $429,803 $0 $0 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 268
Viewing 1 - 50 of 268

How much is your home worth?

...get instant property value now!

The data relating to real estate displayed on this website comes in part from the Heartland Multiple Listing Service database compilation. The properties displayed on this website may not be all of the properties in the Heartland MLS database compilation, or all of the properties listed with other brokers participating in the Heartland MLS IDX program. Detailed information about the properties displayed on this website includes the name of the listing company.

The information displayed on this page is confidential, proprietary, and copyrighted information of Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. (“Heartland MLS”). Copyright 2026, Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Heartland MLS and the company represented by this website do not make any warranty or representation concerning the timeliness or accuracy of the information displayed herein. In consideration for the receipt of the information on this page, the recipient agrees to use the information solely for the private noncommercial purpose of identifying a property in which the recipient has a good faith interest in acquiring. Data last updated . Terms of Use